Site icon

Who Should Be the 5th Starter for the Cleveland Indians?

One of the prominent questions surrounding the Cleveland Indians this off-season is “Who will be the 5th starter?” The final spot in the rotation will most likely be earned in spring training, so we will have to wait a few months to hear the answer. Either way, this question raises some debate as to who deserves it and who doesn’t. In this article, I’ll be breaking down all the candidates for the 5th spot and telling you who I think deserves the last spot in the rotation.

Right now, the Indians have the first four spots in the rotation set. It currently includes Cy Young winner Corey Kluber, Carlos Carrasco, Trevor Bauer, and the newly-signed Gavin Floyd. The 5th spot is up in the air, and there are four guys who all believe they deserve it – Josh Tomlin, Zach McAllister, Danny Salazar, and T.J. House. All have had their ups and downs in the past, but there are some who have a better shot at the 5th spot than others.

First candidate: Josh Tomlin.

via cleveland.com

After being injured for the majority of the 2013 season, Josh Tomlin came into 2014 with the goal of earning a starting spot over Carlos Carrasco. Tomlin lost the battle to Carrasco in spring training, but he was still given plenty of opportunities to start throughout the year.

Tomlin’s first start of 2014 came on May 6th, where he went 6 and 2/3rd innings against the Minnesota Twins, earning his first win of the season in the process. Tomlin ended the month of May with a 3-2 record and a 3.02 ERA. His solid month of May had Terry Francona thinking he made a mistake in choosing Carrasco over Tomlin. Then, on June 28th, Tomlin had arguably the best outing from an Indians pitcher all season. He threw a one-hit complete game shutout against the Seattle Mariners, striking out ten, and lowering his monthly ERA to 4.30.

Unfortunately for Tomlin, he finished the month of July with a 6.45 ERA, and basically took himself out of the rotation as the season went on. Tomlin showed flashes of a good pitcher early in the year, but he was just not consistent enough to be a lock in the starting five. In my opinion, Josh Tomlin will get the occasional start this year, but he will not earn himself a permanent spot in the rotation. His performance last season did not prove enough, and it seems he will be better suited for either a spot in the bullpen, or as a starter in the minors with the occasional call-up.

Second Candidate: Zach McAllister.

via cleveland.com

Zach McAllister had a strong 2013 season, but his 2014 season was not what we hoped for. McAllister pitched very well in 2013, going 9-9 with a 3.75 ERA. Not great, but not bad either. His 2013 performance was enough to earn himself a spot in the 2014 rotation, and everyone was wondering if he would be able to pitch as well as he did in 2013.

Unfortunately for McAllister, his 2014 season did not go as planned, as he finished with a record of 4-7 to go along with a 5.23 ERA. He actually had a solid start to the year, winning three out of his first four starts. However, his ERA in the month of May was an abysmal 10.67, headlined by a start in which he gave up 8 runs in only one and a third innings of work.

McAllister was also sidelined for almost two months due to injury, but he still regained his spot in the rotation when he returned.  But, the month of August wasn’t much better for the hard-throwing righty, and he eventually found himself coming out of the bullpen for the last few weeks of the season. McAllister did pitch well from the bullpen; in fact, he did not allow a run in 5 appearances. He looked great out of the bullpen for the short time he was there, and I think he will resume that role when the season begins. With a fastball that can touch 99 mph some days, he would be a great pitcher to bring in for an inning or two to throw the hitters off. McAllister, like Tomlin, will likely get a start here-and-there, but he is best suited for a bullpen role.

Third Candidate: Danny Salazar.

via sports.yahoo.com

Danny Salazar is a pitcher full of potential, but he is still far awau from his upside, which is high. Salazar had a good rookie year in 2013, going 2-3 with a 3.12 ERA in 12 starts. Salazar really seemed to come into his own in 2013, but we were all second-guessing ourselves after his mediocre start to the 2014 season.

He finished the month of April with a 6.04 ERA to go along with 4 losses, and was sent down to the minor leagues in the middle of May. Salazar did eventually get the call to return to “the Show” in late July, and he pitched pretty well from then on. He had a sparkling 2.77 ERA during the month of August, and it seemed that the hard-throwing righty was at the level we were hoping for at the beginning of the year.

Salazar seems to be the favorite to earn the last spot in the 2015 rotation, and I believe he has a good shot at it. If he can develop his changeup more and control his fastball, he may be the guy to slide into the Tribe’s permanent starting five. Danny Salazar can be an ace starter some day, and it’s time for him to prove it.

Final Candidate: T.J. House.

via wkyc.com

T.J. House was not somebody we were expecting to see as often as we did in 2014. He ended up pitching in 19 games for the Tribe, and he did a lot better than most of us expected. He finished the season with a record of 5-3, and a 3.35 ERA. House is a crafty lefty that doesn’t necessarily beat hitters with speed, but he always finds a way to get outs. The only down side to House is that he often has a high pitch count when he is not very deep into games. On August 2nd in a game against the Texas Rangers, House pitched 5 shutout innings and only allowed 3 hits to go along with 2 walks, but he only went five innings because his pitch count was sitting at 97. However, on August 31st in a game against the Kansas City Royals, House went 7 strong innings, allowed 1 run on 5 hits, and kept his pitch count at 85.

If I were Francona I would tap T.J. House as the Tribe’s fifth starter in 2015. In a starting rotation with four right handers, it would be nice to have a crafty southpaw like House in the rotation. He finds a way to get outs, he is fairly consistent, and he is a lefty. I believe House has a great opportunity to earn the spot, but anything can happen.

We will just have to wait and see.

Exit mobile version