Robot Home Plate Umpires: Let’s Do It
Alright, I’m always pissed watching the Cleveland Guardians games when I see quite a few questionable calls by the home plate umpire. But now, we live in a world where technology is abundant and the fact that we have a human calling the balls and strikes still is very…interesting.
Now…I get it in this sense.
There’s the symbolism behind the game of baseball, back to where our grandparents played it a certain way and because of that, we have to follow it forever and always.
Honestly, though, it’s time to remove that disposition and just allow for there to be a robotic umpire determining what is right and wrong.
Take a look at this graphic I found from a Boston University article a few years ago.

Not like it’s magically changed on anything in these past few years.
A robot ump truthfully helps not only the pitchers but also the hitters in knowing that what happens is right and they don’t get cheated by wrong calls every game, plus worry about whether they should challenge it or not.
I’m not a fan of being able to challenge balls and strikes when it takes away the responsibility of the human umpire. That’s the idea of a robot never getting it wrong, being completely in charge. Just like a review from the challenge always gets it right by using technology to do so…
What would be the downside of this robot ump change?
Well, the aforementioned idea that it changes the authentic and wholesome part of baseball that everyone loves. There’s the classic part of players and coaches arguing calls with human umpires and even getting thrown out of games, too, spitting in each other’s faces. I’m sure they’d still find matters to get pissed about…
If the calls continue to be bad moving forward, maybe this is something that gets discussed in the coming years to try and get it right.
Looking back, I just wonder how many games in the past would’ve been completely altered if the calls were correctly made by robot umps in every single game. An abundance…that’s for sure.
Lastly, if authenticity is the biggest factor in this entire sense, then take away challenges. Give the responsibility to the human umpire and have teams and fans live with the fact that it’s either a right or wrong call…technically. However, I doubt that the current generation of fans will like that still…
