November 15, 2026
Keep Brendan Sorsby Out of Cleveland

After the NCAA (rightfully) challenged Brendan Sorsby’s injunction last week, the quarterback will be moving on to the NFL through the supplemental draft next month – and as one of the only teams with a starting QB spot still up for grabs, many people expect the Browns to make a bid for him. With the Steelers also expected to submit a major bid to develop him as Aaron Rodgers’ successor, it would be pretty funny to stop them from getting what they want – but if I were Andrew Berry, I would stay as far away as possible. 

Coach Monken, when asked about potentially drafting Sorsby, called the idea a “slippery slope […] irrespective of talent.” While he emphasized that it was his opinion and not Andrew Berry’s, it’s hard to believe that AB would go against his head coach’s vision after staking his career on that same vision just five months ago. Berry might have final say over the roster, but Todd Monken was hired because he believes he can win with the guys we have.

I agree that we shouldn’t go near him, but for a different reason. Don’t get me wrong: the gambling was bad. $90,000 in bets placed is absurd, and betting on your own team (even if you aren’t playing) should come with a harsher penalty than what he’s going to get. With that being said, though, my main issue with Sorsby isn’t his gambling addiction. It’s his performance on the field. 

In my opinion, Brendan Sorsby is a fine college quarterback. In his 2025 season with Cincinnati, he posted nearly 3400 total yards with 36 total touchdowns and just six total turnovers. On the surface, those are great numbers – and many analysts predict that they will likely earn him a day-two price tag in the upcoming draft. If you break the stats down by opponent, however, they tell a different story. 

Of Sorsby’s 2800 passing yards, 1540 of them (along with 17 passing touchdowns) came in his five games against bottom-50% pass defenses. In his seven games against the top half of the country, Brendan Sorsby completed 102 of his 191 passes (53.4%) for 1260 yards and a 10:5 touchdown-to-interception ratio. Against real competition, his 180 yards and 1.4 touchdowns per game were a stark contrast from the 300+ yards and 3+ passing touchdowns he averaged against the bottom half. If Sorsby can’t keep up with the top half of college talent, why should we trust him to figure it out against the best of the best?

If this were a normal draft, there were no gambling scandal and we really needed a quarterback, he might be worth a mid-to-late round flier pick. But it isn’t, there is, and we don’t. I may not trust either Shedeur or Deshaun to be the long-term franchise starter, but I trust the faith Todd Monken has shown in them more than I trust Brendan Sorsby.

Even if I was confident in his ability to eventually translate his game to the NFL level, I don’t see a reason to force a third quarterback – especially an unpolished and unproven one – into the middle of an active position battle with so little time before the season begins.

If our current options don’t pan out and we need another starter in 2027, I’d prefer to have as much draft capital as possible if we need to move up and get our guy. I might not know who the next face of the franchise will be, but I know it shouldn’t be Brendan Sorsby. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com