Assessing The Trade Value of Josh Naylor and Lane Thomas
Coming off an ALCS appearance, the Guardians enter the offseason with major issues with starting pitching. So, why would trading Josh Naylor and Lane Thomas be a topic at the MLB winter meetings in Dallas?
Both players will be free agents next season and are unlikely to resign from the team. This is not surprising if you’ve followed the team over the past 30 years. Ownership, led by Paul Dolan, has not been willing to spend money consistently in bringing talent. Outside of signing Jose Ramirez a nine-figure contract, no player has been signed to significant dollars. Historically, Cleveland has ranked in the bottom half of Major League Baseball in team payroll, including finishing 23rd with just over $105 million.
Naylor, who made his first all-star game last season, is a home-grown product who has hit for power averaging 24 home runs the past three seasons. He has a combined .267/.330/.465 batting line (batting average, slugging %, and on-base %) over those three years for a 121 wRC+ (weighted runs created plus), indicating he was 21% better than the league average in that stretch. However, an increase in strikeouts and a decrease in batting average last season poses a concern for entering a contract year. Naylor is a solid defensive player who has almost 3,000 innings of first-base work under his belt producing. His $12M salary, should give him plenty of appeal this offseason from teams such as the Padres, Rangers, and Yankees.
Thomas, a postseason hero, is likely to have less appeal on the trade market. His projected salary is a little lower but his ability to contribute is also smaller as he’s a right-handed hitter who is better against lefties. For his career, he has slashed .302/.366/.514 with the platoon advantage for a 140 wRC+, but .223/.290/.391 against righties for an 87 wRC+. Defensively, he’s versatile in playing all three outfield positions but plays mostly center field. The platoon splits suggest he would be best utilized in a part-time role, but the lack of center-field options in free agency could work in his favor. Keep an eye on the Blue Jays and Cardinals as they were both one of the worst teams facing left-handed pitching last season
The reality is trading Naylor and Thomas would bring back young, controllable assets in the future to sustain the team for future success. It’s unfortunate as both players made key plays in the playoffs, but this is how ownership and the front office operates. Both are popular in the locker room and Naylor’s younger brother, Bo, was on the postseason roster. I’d guess that one of them gets traded in the offseason and if the team is not playing well going into the trade deadline, both will be gone.
